Map Extract
Free tool

Flat Rate Scheme or standard VAT? Compare the two

Enter yearly sales before VAT, pick your business type from HMRC's list, and add the VAT on your costs and your spend on relevant goods. The calculator shows the VAT you would pay under each method and whether the flat rate saves or costs you money.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is uploaded.

Comparing the two methods

  1. Enter sales before VAT

    Your yearly turnover net of VAT. The tool adds the VAT you charge to get the VAT-inclusive turnover the flat rate is applied to.

  2. Pick your business type

    The list follows HMRC's flat rate categories, each with its percentage, such as 14% for management consultancy or 12% for business services not listed elsewhere.

  3. Enter the VAT on your costs

    What you could reclaim each year under standard accounting. It is the main thing you give up by joining the scheme.

  4. Enter spend on relevant goods

    Goods used only for the business, including VAT. Services, fuel, food and capital items do not count. This feeds the limited cost business test.

  5. Say if it is your first year

    In the first year of VAT registration the flat rate is 1% lower, which the tool applies when you choose Yes.

Example: a consultancy that buys almost nothing

A sales training consultant sells £62,000 a year before VAT, charges 20% and reclaims about £900 of VAT on costs. Under standard accounting she pays £12,400 minus £900, which is £11,500.

Her sector rate is 14%, but she spends only £400 on relevant goods, under the £1,488 test level, so the 16.5% limited cost rate applies to her £74,400 VAT-inclusive turnover. That is £12,276, so the flat rate costs her £776 more. If she genuinely bought £2,000 of relevant goods, her 14% rate would apply, giving £10,416 and a saving of £1,084.

Input
Sales £62,000 before VAT, charging 20%
Management consultancy (14%)
VAT on costs £900
Relevant goods £400, not first year
Result
Flat rate costs you more: £776.00
Standard VAT to pay £11,500.00
Flat rate VAT at 16.5% £12,276.00
VAT-inclusive turnover £74,400.00

Other points the result reminds you of

You cannot join the scheme if you expect taxable sales above £150,000 before VAT in the next year, and the tool says so when your figure is over that level. Buying goods just to pass the limited cost test does not make sense unless you need them: the tax saving is usually smaller than the money spent.

The scheme mainly suits businesses with few costs carrying VAT. It also keeps bookkeeping simpler, which some owners value for its own sake. HMRC's flat rate guidance lists the sector percentages and what counts as relevant goods.

Questions people ask

Is the VAT Flat Rate Scheme worth it?

It depends on your sector rate, your costs and whether the limited cost test applies. A business with few VAT-bearing costs and real spending on goods often saves money; a pure service business caught by the 16.5% rate often pays more than under standard accounting. The calculator compares both for your figures.

What counts as relevant goods for the limited cost test?

Goods used only for the business, such as stock or stationery. Services, capital items, food and drink for staff, vehicles and fuel are excluded. The calculator asks for the VAT-inclusive total of relevant goods and compares it with 2% of turnover or £1,000 a year.

Can I reclaim VAT on purchases under the flat rate scheme?

Generally no, apart from single capital assets costing £2,000 or more including VAT. That lost input VAT is why the calculator asks for the VAT on your costs: it shows what standard accounting would have let you reclaim, and the comparison only makes sense with it included.

Do I still charge my customers 20% VAT?

Yes. Your invoices show VAT at the normal rate and customers pay it as usual. The scheme only changes your own sum for HMRC: one sector percentage applied to gross takings, in place of the VAT you charged less the VAT you paid on costs.

Where your data goes

Sales, costs and sector choices are compared by the page in your browser. No turnover figures are posted to Map Extract or kept after the visit.

Checked against the tool on

Top