Map Extract
Free tool

Rent or buy? Compare the two over time

Fill in the home price, deposit, mortgage, buying and selling costs, upkeep, expected price growth, current rent, rent rises and the return you could earn on savings. The calculator follows both paths month by month and tells you which leaves you better off after the number of years you choose.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is uploaded.

How the comparison works

The buyer pays the deposit and buying costs, makes the mortgage payment and pays upkeep each month. At the end, their wealth is the home's value after growth, less selling costs and the mortgage still owed.

The renter keeps the deposit and buying costs invested instead, and each month also invests whatever the buyer spends on mortgage and upkeep above the rent. Their wealth is that invested pot at the end. Rent rises once a year by the percentage you set.

Running your own numbers

  1. Buying side

    Home price, deposit, mortgage rate and term, buying costs (stamp duty, solicitor, survey), selling costs as a percentage, and yearly upkeep as a percentage of value.

  2. Growth assumption

    House price growth a year. This has the biggest effect on the answer, so try several values.

  3. Renting side

    Monthly rent now, how much it rises each year, and the return you expect on money you invest instead of buying.

  4. Choose the period

    How many years to compare. Short periods favour renting, because buying and selling costs have less time to be recovered.

  5. Read and adjust

    The result says which is better and shows both wealth figures. Change the growth and return assumptions to see how sensitive the answer is.

Example: a couple renting in Nottingham

A couple pay £1,250 a month in rent and are looking at a £260,000 house with a £39,000 deposit, a 25-year mortgage at 4.6% and £7,500 of buying costs. They assume 2.5% price growth, 3% rent rises, 1% upkeep, 2% selling costs and a 4% return on savings, over 8 years.

The mortgage payment is £1,240.97. After 8 years the buyer's equity after selling would be £135,043.87, against £75,114.96 in the renter's invested pot, so buying comes out ahead. They would have paid £133,385.04 in rent over the period. With zero price growth, buying still edges it at £79,394.81 against £73,683.91, which tells them the result does not hang on prices rising.

Input
Price £260,000, deposit £39,000, 4.6% over 25 years
Buying costs £7,500, selling 2%, upkeep 1%
Growth 2.5%, rent £1,250 rising 3%, savings return 4%
Compare over 8 years
Result
Better off: Buying
Buyer's wealth (equity after sale) £135,043.87
Renter's wealth (invested savings) £75,114.96
Mortgage payment £1,240.97

Questions people ask

Is it better to rent or buy?

It depends on how long you stay, house price growth, rent rises and what you would earn on the money instead. Over short periods renting often wins because buying and selling costs dominate; over longer ones buying usually catches up. The calculator lets you test your own assumptions side by side.

What counts as buying costs?

Everything you pay to complete the purchase apart from the deposit: stamp duty or LBTT, solicitor or conveyancer fees, searches, a survey and any mortgage arrangement fee. Use the stamp duty calculators on this site to get the tax part, then add your quotes.

Why does the renter invest the difference?

To make the comparison fair. If buying costs more each month than renting, a renter who spends that difference would obviously end up poorer. Assuming they invest it measures what each choice does to your wealth, not just your monthly spending.

How much should I allow for upkeep?

Many people use around 1% of the home's value a year for repairs and maintenance, which is the default here, but older homes often need more. Change the upkeep percentage to see how much it moves the result for the property you are considering.

Where your data goes

All twelve inputs are processed in the page on your device. Nothing is sent to estate agents, lenders or Map Extract.

Checked against the tool on

Top