Comparing the two
Enter the day rate and days a year
The rate the client or agency pays, before VAT. 220 days is the default; reduce it for holidays and gaps between contracts.
Set your outside IR35 costs
Business expenses the company would pay, such as an accountant, insurance and equipment, and the director salary you take, £12,570 by default.
Set the umbrella's margin and levy
The umbrella company's annual fee and whether it deducts the 0.5% Apprenticeship Levy from your pay budget, as many do.
Read the table
Contract value, expenses or margin, employer NI and levy, Corporation Tax, salary, dividends, your tax and NI, and take-home, side by side.
Example: a £450 a day contract
A freelance CRM consultant (fictional) is offered 220 days at £450, which is £99,000 a year. Inside IR35 through an umbrella charging £1,100 a year and deducting the levy, the employer NI and levy come out of the rate before any salary is paid, leaving a gross salary of £85,411.25 and take-home of £60,095.92.
Through the consultant's own limited company, after £3,000 of costs and a director's salary of £12,570, Corporation Tax comes to £18,058.04 and the remaining profit is paid as dividends, for take-home of £63,320.68. The difference is £3,224.76 a year, smaller than many contractors expect.
Day rate: £450 Days worked a year: 220 Business expenses outside IR35: £3,000 Director salary outside IR35: £12,570 Umbrella margin: £1,100 a year Umbrella deducts Apprenticeship Levy: Yes, 0.5%
Outside IR35 take-home: £63,320.68 Inside IR35 (umbrella) take-home: £60,095.92 Difference a year: £3,224.76 Inside as % of outside: 94.9%
Why the gap is not bigger
Outside IR35 the profit is taxed twice: Corporation Tax in the company, then dividend tax on what you take out, and dividend rates rose from April 2026. Inside IR35 the contract value has to fund employer NI and often the levy before you see a penny, then income tax and employee NI apply. At higher day rates and with dividends reaching the higher rate band, the two routes end up closer than the headlines suggest.
The comparison assumes no pension contributions, one director and all profit paid out. Pension contributions, through salary sacrifice inside or employer contributions outside, change the picture considerably and are worth modelling with an accountant.
Questions people ask
How much less do you take home inside IR35?
It depends on the day rate, days, expenses and umbrella fees. In the example on this page, a £450 day rate over 220 days gives about 95% of the outside IR35 take-home when paid through an umbrella. Enter your own figures; the gap is usually larger at lower rates and with higher business expenses.
Who decides whether a contract is inside IR35?
For engagements with medium and large private sector clients and all public sector bodies, the client must decide and issue a Status Determination Statement. For small clients, the contractor's own company decides. HMRC's guidance on off-payroll working sets out the rules and the size tests.
Why does the umbrella take employer National Insurance from my rate?
An umbrella company employs you, so it has to pay employer NI and, where it applies, the Apprenticeship Levy. These are funded from the contract rate before your gross salary is set. That is legal and common, but compare umbrellas on take-home, not only on their advertised margin.
Does the calculator include pensions or VAT?
No. It assumes no pension contributions in either route, and works on the day rate before VAT, since VAT charged by a limited company is passed to HMRC. If you are on the Flat Rate Scheme, the small surplus it can create is not included either.
Where your data goes
Rates, days and costs go no further than the calculator running in this page. Your contract details are not sent to any agency, umbrella company or this site.
Checked against the tool on